In-N-Out Sauces Menu 2025: Every Sauce Explained + How to Order Extras
Looking to level up your next In-N-Out order? Whether you’re new to the iconic burger chain or a seasoned fan, In-N-Out’s sauces menu is key to customizing your meal. From the famous Spread to dipping sauces and secret add-ons, this guide breaks down everything you need to know — including ingredients, ordering tips, and how to recreate the flavor at home.
What’s Inside the Famous In-N-Out Spread?
The Spread is In-N-Out’s signature burger topping, and it’s a big part of what gives their burgers that nostalgic flavor. While the exact recipe is proprietary, copycat versions and taste tests suggest these ingredients:
Mayonnaise
The creamy base of the sauce
Ketchup
Adds sweetness and that signature red color
Sweet pickle relish
Tiny bits of sweet pickles for crunch and tang
White vinegar
Gives the sauce its sharp bite
Sugar
Balances the acidity
Salt and black pepper
For seasoning
Paprika
Adds a hint of smoky depth
Garlic powder
Boosts the flavor
Onion powder
Adds that savory kick
How to Customize and Order Extra Sauce
You can definitely get extra sauce — and here’s how:
How to Ask:
| Ordering Method | How to Request Extra Spread |
|---|---|
| In-Store | “Can I get extra Spread on the side, please?” |
| Drive-Thru | “Add two packets of Spread, please.” |
| Mobile Orders | Use the comment or customization box (if available). |
Customization Tips:
| Customization | Description |
|---|---|
| Sauce on the Side | Great for dipping fries or spreading more on your burger. |
| Extra Spread on Your Burger | Double the tangy goodness. |
| Grilled Mustard Patty | Ask for “mustard grilled” for extra flavor depth. |
For Animal Style orders, Spread is already applied generously along with grilled onions and pickles.
Can You Buy In-N-Out Sauce?
While In-N-Out doesn’t sell bottled Spread in stores or online, you can get extra packets when you order.
Ordering Options:
| Method | Details |
|---|---|
| At the Restaurant | Request additional packets — typically free or for a small charge. |
| Online? | Nope. In-N-Out doesn’t offer sauce online or in retail stores. |
| DIY Copycat Recipes | Many bloggers and chefs recreate it at home. Search: “In-N-Out Spread copycat recipe.” |
Best Sauce Combos & Dipping Tips
Want to go beyond the basics? Try these combos:
| Combo / Customization | Description |
|---|---|
| Spread + Ketchup | Sweet and tangy — perfect for fries. |
| Double Spread | Ask for extra Spread on burgers or fries for that Animal Style taste without onions. |
| Grilled Mustard Patty + Spread | Extra savory and balanced flavor combo. |
Pro tip: Order Spread on the side to dip both burger and fries for max flavor control.
Is the Sauce Vegan, Gluten-Free, or Keto?
Spread:
| Dietary Concern | Status |
|---|---|
| Vegan | ❌ Not vegan – contains mayonnaise (eggs) |
| Keto-Friendly | ❌ Not keto – contains sugar and relish (carbs) |
| Gluten-Free | ✅ Yes, but confirm due to potential cross-contamination |
For low-carb or keto, ask for a “protein-style” burger (lettuce wrap) and go light on the Spread or skip it entirely.
How In-N-Out Sauce Compares to Others
Wondering how In-N-Out stacks up against other burger joints?
| Brand | Sauce Description |
|---|---|
| Shake Shack Sauce | More mayo-based and less tangy than In-N-Out’s Spread |
| McDonald’s Big Mac Sauce | Sweeter, more pickle-forward |
| Five Guys | Offers a wider variety of sauces, but none quite match the Spread’s balance |
Still, most fans agree: In-N-Out’s Spread is what makes their burgers legendary.
Conclusion:
Whether you’re customizing your Animal Style burger or just need the perfect fry dip, understanding the In-N-Out sauces menu is your ticket to flavor heaven. From classic Spread to creative combos, there’s more to explore than meets the eye.
FAQ’s of In-N-Out Sauce Menu
In-N-Out sauce is a creamy, tangy, and slightly sweet spread. It’s similar to Thousand Island dressing. While the exact recipe is a secret, it typically includes:, Mayonnaise, Ketchup, Sweet pickle relish, Vinegar, Sugar, Spices
This combination gives the sauce its unique flavor that pairs perfectly with burgers and fries.
In-N-Out does not sell their sauce in bottles or containers at their restaurants. However, you can ask for extra sauce on the side when you order
Yes! This is a popular item from the In-N-Out secret menu. If you ask for Animal Style Fries, your fries will be topped with melted cheese, grilled onions, and a generous drizzle of their signature sauce.
In-N-Out doesn’t list their sauce as certified gluten-free. However, many customers with gluten sensitivity report no issues when eating the sauce. Still, if you have severe gluten allergies, it’s best to check with staff at your local location to be safe.
If you love the In-N-Out sauce menu, you might want to try making it at home. While the official recipe is secret, many copycat recipes online come close:
Yes! All burgers at In-N-Out come with their signature spread by default, unless you ask for it to be removed. You can also customize your burger by adding more sauce or swapping it out for mustard or ketchup.
One packet or serving of In-N-Out sauce contains about 80–100 calories, depending on the size. If you’re watching your calories, you can ask for “light spread” or no spread at all.